Traditional automakers face struggling against emerging electric vehicle manufacturers: why does transitioning present such a formidable challenge?
In the rapidly evolving world of electric vehicles (EVs), Chinese manufacturers are making significant strides, leaving many legacy carmakers in their dust. This shift is primarily due to several key factors that have allowed Chinese automakers to build technological and market advantages, according to industry experts.
China, with its massive domestic market, accounts for over 11 million electric vehicle sales annually, more than half of global EV sales. Chinese automakers have leveraged this huge market to build significant economies of scale, enabling them to advance their EV technologies rapidly.
Early and sustained investment in electrification has also been a significant advantage for Chinese manufacturers. While legacy automakers are still catching up, Chinese companies have made strategic investments that have given them a technological edge.
Innovative operating models have further propelled the growth of Chinese EV manufacturers. China's "new operating model" allows automakers to bring vehicles to market twice as fast, with 40–50% less investment and a 30% cost advantage over competitors. AI-enabled solutions have further cut development times and costs by about 20%.
Aggressive pricing strategies have also boosted demand for EVs in China, with companies like BYD using price cuts to clear inventory and grow sales, albeit at the expense of profit margins.
Unlike Tesla, which focuses mainly on battery electric vehicles (BEVs), firms like BYD and Geely produce both BEVs and plug-in hybrids (PHEVs), broadening their market reach within China’s NEV segment. Scalable platforms, such as Geely’s Sustainable Experience Architecture (SEA), support rapid production and expansion.
The Chinese government's strong support for electrification and zero-emission vehicles has created a favorable regulatory environment, unlike Western counterparts who face more uncertain and complex regulations. This support has allowed Chinese EV makers to surge ahead in the global electrification race.
While legacy automakers like Toyota face challenges in rapidly transitioning due to their existing investments in internal combustion engine technology, slower innovation cycles, and complex regulatory landscapes in the U.S. and EU, the new players in the EV market are not burdened by legacy mindsets, investments, or structures.
As the market transformation speeds up, Toyota's strategy risks anchoring the company to a slower, legacy-driven trajectory. In contrast, Chinese EV makers, such as BYD, Nio, Xpeng, and even tech companies like Xiaomi, are leading the way in transformation, with advantages in integration and simplicity, software-first mentality, global expansion, innovation speed, and production of advanced vehicles.
Joining the Fleet APAC Community provides access to a monthly newsletter featuring the latest trends and developments in the EV sector, keeping you updated on this exciting race towards the future of mobility. Clicking here allows for joining the Fleet APAC Community.
However, tariffs and protectionist measures may temporarily shield Western carmakers, but unless they use that time to accelerate real transformation, they risk losing far more than market share – they risk losing their future. It's no longer enough to just be good at making cars; you have to be good at changing what a car – and a carmaker – actually is.
[1] Source: BloombergNEF, McKinsey & Company, Reuters, and China EV100. [2] Source: Reuters, Forbes, and Geely. [3] Source: BloombergNEF, Reuters, and BYD. [4] Source: McKinsey & Company and China EV100.
- The rapid growth of electric vehicles (EVs) is primarily driven by China's domestic market, where over 11 million EV sales occur annually, more than half of global EV sales.
- Chinese automakers have utilized this vast market to rapidly advance their EV technologies, benefiting from significant economies of scale.
- Early and sustained investment in electrification, innovative operating models, and AI-enabled solutions have given Chinese EV manufacturers a technological edge over legacy automakers.
- Chinese EV makers have also benefited from a favorable regulatory environment and are leading the way in transformation, with advantages in integration and simplicity, software-first mentality, global expansion, innovation speed, and production of advanced vehicles.
