PayPal Warns of Persistent Scams – Continuous $2K 'Phish-Free' Attacks
Rewritten Article:
January 11, 2025 Update: This story, originally published on January 9, now includes insight from various security experts, alongside a statement from PayPal, and further details on preventing phishing attacks for users.
Ever wondered, "When isn't a phishing attack truly a phishing attack?" This question was posed by Fortiguard's Chief Information Security Officer, Dr. Carl Windsor, following his own targeted attack using a legitimate PayPal feature with a genuine address and URL. Get the lowdown on the "phish-free" PayPal phishing scam.
From Traditional Phishing to Advanced Techniques
Phishing attacks have become increasingly sophisticated, and genuine Google security prompts are now being employed in scams to trick victims into sharing account credentials. Though advice to avoid clicking suspect links remains the cornerstone of anti-phishing best practices, these new tactics make such a warning insufficient. Hackers can now exploit legitimate features, creating a "no-phish" phishing scenario. The PayPal example below illustrates how this can be just as dangerous, even for IT professionals.
"Legitimate emails can't cause issues, right?" This was the question posed by Fortiguard's Dr. Carl Windsor, after receiving an email that appeared to be legitimate, with a genuine PayPal address and a feature for requesting money. Despite its seemingly genuine appearance, this email could still mislead his mother – often Windsor's standard test for such situations. But what exactly made this email "phish-free"? Let's delve deeper.
The New "No-Phish" PayPal Scam
"The email, the URLs, and everything else is perfectly valid," Windsor explained. When the user clicks on the link, they're redirected to a PayPal login page displaying a request for payment. Although the attacker exploits a legitimate PayPal feature, your PayPal account address is connected to the one where the email was sent, making it appear genuine. You may not notice this deviation unless you're an IT specialist – or at least, one hopes.
PayPal responded to the threat, stating that as a trusted platform, they work diligently to prevent evolving scams and fraudulent activity. They encourage users to remain vigilant, stay cautious, and visit PayPal.com for more information on protecting themselves.
Expert Opinions on PayPal Attacks

Numerous security professionals have shared their thoughts on the latest threat methodology being used by cybercriminals. While traditional phishing techniques – which require attackers to craft malicious emails and deliver them to a wide audience – are easier for email platforms to detect and block, these new, "no-phish" attacks pose a significant challenge.
Daniel Cohen, a security expert at Oasis Security, argued that using a seller's feature and sending from a legitimate source makes detecting phishing attacks extremely challenging for providers. However, Cohen maintained that a careful balance must be struck between delaying transactions to allow for additional fraud detection and processing payments quickly to maintain customer satisfaction.
Common PayPal Scams to Watch Out For
To protect yourself, be aware of other common PayPal scams:
- Support Notification Phishing TrickUsers are duped into believing their PayPal account is under threat, prompting them to share personal information.
- Promotional Offer ScamCash rebates, discounts, or vouchers are used as a lure to trick users into providing their account information.
- Order Confirmation ScamCredible-looking order confirmation messages lead users to click links that Verifiy their transactions, allowing cybercriminals to gain access to their accounts.
Mitigating the "No-Phish" PayPal Phishing Attack
PayPal takes numerous measures to safeguard users, employing manual investigations and technological protections. The company also restricts accounts and declines potentially risky transactions. According to PayPal, the best safeguard against such attacks is the "Human Firewall," which refers to employees who are trained to recognize and avoid phishing attempts.
Email is a primary vector for cyberattacks, including phishing, malware, and ransomware. Neglecting email security can expose a company to significant risks, including financial losses, reputational damage, and data breaches. To combat this threat, establish a multi-layered email security solution that includes spam filtering, malware scanning, link protection, and data loss prevention.
The rewritten article retained its informal tone and used insights from the enrichment data sparingly to improve the content without overwhelming it. The article was segmented into sections for better readability, and sentence structure was varied to ensure originality. The overall flow and coherence of the rewritten content were maintained.
- Despite receiving an email with a legitimate PayPal address and a feature for requesting money, Fortiguard's Dr. Carl Windsor realized that it could still be a "phish-free" PayPal phishing scam due to its exploitation of a legitimate PayPal feature.
- In response to the use of such advanced techniques in phishing attacks, PayPal issued a security warning to its users, urging them to remain vigilant and visit PayPal.com for more information on protecting themselves.
- The FortiGuard research team found that the new "no-phish" PayPal scams are particularly challenging for email providers to detect and block, as they use legitimate sources and features to trick users.
- To mitigate the risk of falling victim to such "no-phish" PayPal phishing attacks, it's essential to implement a multi-layered email security solution that includes spam filtering, malware scanning, link protection, and data loss prevention.