Outboard Engine Showdown: Gas vs. Electric Powered Engines - Real-world Examination
In the world of boating, the choice between petrol and electric outboard motors is becoming a hot topic. For small boats and tenders, electric outboards are increasingly favoured for their environmental benefits and quiet operation, particularly in sensitive areas.
**Petrol Outboard Motors**
Petrol outboard motors, a mainstay in boating for decades, offer several advantages. With a strong power-to-weight ratio, they are powerful and efficient for their size. They are portable and easy to replace, making them ideal for users seeking flexibility. The ability to tilt them out of the water helps avoid fouling and damage, and their handling is good due to the entire motor pivoting with the tiller.
However, petrol outboards do have drawbacks. They produce emissions and noise pollution, which can disturb wildlife and the boating environment. Regular maintenance such as fuel system checks, oil changes, and winterizing is required. Fuel handling and storage can also be inconvenient and potentially hazardous.
**Electric Outboard Motors**
Electric outboard motors, on the other hand, are environmentally friendly with zero emissions and significantly less noise pollution. Lithium battery technology offers good power and range for small boats, and their quiet operation allows for peaceful boating experiences. Lower maintenance is another advantage due to fewer moving parts and no fuel system to manage.
However, electric outboards do have their limitations. They generally have a higher upfront cost, range and power may be limited by battery capacity and hull speed, and battery weight and charging infrastructure can be considerations for extended use. Some electric motors still require separate battery systems or have limited runtime, which can be a drawback for long trips.
**Comparing the Two**
A summary table outlines the key differences between petrol and electric outboard motors in terms of power and performance, noise and emissions, maintenance, cost, portability, and environmental impact.
The choice between the two depends on your boating style, environmental priorities, and budget. For those prioritizing longer range and quick refueling, petrol outboards might still be the preferred choice. However, for those seeking a quiet, eco-friendly boating experience, electric outboards are becoming an increasingly popular choice.
**A Personal Perspective**
One individual, who has a history of using outboard motors since the 80s, recently made the switch to an electric outboard motor. The individual, who commutes daily using an inflatable tender with an electric outboard motor, considers it the best decision. The individual's electric outboard motor, a slightly used Remigo, costs roughly £2000. The individual can go all week without needing to charge the motor, topping up the battery as needed, either from their onboard boat battery bank, solar power, or by charging it during the day at their office.
While electric outboard motors initially have a higher cost, the individual believes the long-term savings in fuel and maintenance make it a worthwhile investment. The individual can control the autopilot from a Garmin watch, enhancing the boating experience.
In conclusion, the evolution of outboard motors is an exciting development in the boating world. As technology advances, the choice between petrol and electric outboard motors will continue to be a topic of interest for boaters.
[1] Source: Boat International [2] Source: The Guardian [3] Source: Yachting Monthly [4] Source: Outboard Motor Guide
Sailing techniques can benefit greatly from the quiet operation of electric outboard motors, as they allow for a more peaceful boating lifestyle without disturbing wildlife.
As technology advances, lifestyle preferences increasingly lean towards the environmentally friendly attributes of electric outboard motors, offering zero emissions and reduced noise pollution.
